Two double beats… but only one buyer showed up. The charts told you exactly how it would play out.
April 1, 2026
Stocks rallied into quarter-end yesterday, putting a strong finish on a weak Q1.
But underneath the surface, earnings reactions continue to separate the winners from the losers… and more importantly, the bottoms from the breakdowns.
And yesterday gave us a perfect case study.
We had 2 companies, 2 double beats, and 2 completely different outcomes.
Let’s start with the Beat Sheet.
*Click the image to enlarge it
Both FactSet $FDS and McCormick $MKC delivered better-than-expected revenue and earnings. The fundamental story, at least on the surface, looked solid across the board.
But the price trends were anything but...
Both stocks are in primary downtrends. That much is clear. But where they are within those downtrends is what mattered most.
And that’s where the market made its decision.
FDS rallied over 6% on its report, its best earnings reaction since Q2 2022.
Meanwhile, McCormick dropped more than 6%, marking its third consecutive negative reaction.
These were seemingly the same earnings, but the outcomes were polar opposite.
Now let’s talk about why.
FactSet has already gone through the pain.
After resolving a massive multi-year top last year, the stock has been cut by more than half. That’s the kind of move that resets expectations.
Now it’s back at a key level of interest.
That $180 zone was resistance for years in 2015, 2016, and 2017.
Then it flipped to support in 2018.
Now it’s back at the scene of the crime, and now we’re seeing buyers step in right where they should.
The fundamentals help support that story...
FactSet continues to grow its top line at a healthy clip, with Q2 sales up over 7% year-over-year and subscription value expanding by nearly 7% as well.
Even with some margin compression, the business is still generating strong cash flow and benefiting from increased demand across institutional and wealth clients.
In other words, the business is still working.
So when you combine a washed-out chart with a still-growing business, you get exactly what we saw: buyers showing up on good news.
That doesn’t mean it’s straight up from here because bottoms are processes, not events.
But this is how they begin.
As long as FactSet holds that $180 level, the risk is defined and the case for a base-building process remains intact. Lose that level, and all bets are off.
Now compare that to McCormick.
This is a completely different story...
McCormick hasn’t finished going down.
Yes, the company delivered strong operational results, with growth in sales, operating income, and earnings.
And strategically, management is leaning into a major combination with Unilever’s food business to drive long-term growth and synergies.
On paper, that sounds great.
But the market doesn’t care about the story when the trend is down, and the trend here is very clearly down.
McCormick peaked back in early 2022 and has been grinding lower ever since.
And now, it’s decisively resolving a textbook distribution pattern.
Unlike FactSet, which already resolved its top and is attempting to stabilize, McCormick is just now entering the most dangerous phase of the cycle, the breakdown after a prolonged topping pattern.
And the market is treating it accordingly.
Three straight negative earnings reactions tell you everything you need to know.
The sellers are still in control of MKC, and the path of least resistance is lower for the foreseeable future.
If you want to trade the stocks with the strongest technicals and fundamentals, check out the work we're doing for Premium Beat Report members and consider joining our growing community.
Welcome to the beginning of Q2,
-The Beat Team
P.S. Sam Gatlin and Jason Perz will be joined by JC Parets for a live session called "Making Money from Inflation" this Thursday at 2 pm ET.
It's all about trading commodities. It's free, live, and we’ll have plenty of time for Q&A at the end.
