In most parts of life, the rule is simple — follow the leader.
But in the bond market, the game’s a little different. Here, it’s more like carry the follower.
That’s exactly what we’re seeing play out right now between short term and long term Treasury bonds. The 1–3 Year Treasury Bond ETF $SHY has started to climb, showing signs of strength and stability. But the 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF $TLT still lags behind, weighed down by something heavier — inflation expectations.
In other words, SHY is trying to carry TLT up the hill, but TLT’s got a backpack full of bricks labeled inflation.
Short Term Bonds Leading, Long Term Bonds Lagging
This chart makes the point crystal clear.
The black line $SHY has already started moving higher — short term rates are stabilizing as investors sense the Federal Reserve may continue cutting rates. But look at the green line $TLT. It’s still stuck in the mud, unable to rally with the same conviction.
That divergence tells us something important about the macro environment:
When short term bonds lead and long term bonds lag, it’s usually a “reflation” regime. Growth and inflation are both moving higher, but not at runaway levels.
Investors expect the economy to hold up, which benefits equities and select commodities — sectors like speculative tech, industrial metals, and small caps tend to thrive in this phase.
Reflation is the sweet spot of the cycle. Inflation is rising, but moderately. Growth is accelerating, and risk assets are rewarded.
The challenge is balance. If inflation starts to heat up too quickly, the “weight” on TLT becomes too heavy. Long duration bonds will sink again, signaling that markets are bracing for more inflation or higher yields ahead.
Energy vs. Bonds — The Tug of War
To see this dynamic from another angle, look at the Energy sector $XLE versus long term Treasuries $TLT. These two are often on opposite sides of the rope in the inflation tug of war.
When inflation expectations rise:
Energy stocks like $XLE tend to move higher.
Long-term bonds $TLT typically come under pressure and move lower.
When inflation expectations fall:
Bonds find support and rally.
Energy and commodities tend to cool off.
Lately, though, something interesting has happened. Despite the pressure from TLT, energy hasn’t broken down. $XLE has quietly stabilized and is trying to trend higher again.
That resilience in energy, even as TLT struggles, tells us the market still sees inflation as sticky — not collapsing. The reflation theme is alive, and the leadership baton hasn’t fully passed back to bonds yet.
The Key Signal to Watch
So what happens next?
Keep your eye on TLT. If it starts to follow SHY higher, it means inflation pressure is easing — that “weight” is being lifted, and the bond market can breathe again.
But if TLT continues to lag, while energy and commodities keep grinding up, it’s a sign that inflation might be reaccelerating. That would reinforce a reflationary environment — strong for cyclicals and commodities, but challenging for long-duration assets like bonds and consumer staples.
Think of SHY as the one trying to pull the sled uphill. TLT is sitting on that sled, loaded with the heavy baggage of inflation expectations. The more inflation sticks around, the heavier TLT feels. The moment it starts to lighten up and move, the whole market tone could shift.
Bottom Line
This is the market’s version of a tug of war — not between bulls and bears, but between growth and inflation.
Right now, short term bonds are leading, energy is holding firm, and long term bonds are trying to find their footing. That’s a reflationary setup — one where stocks, cyclicals, and real assets tend to outperform.
The question now is simple:
Who wins the tug of war — the sled or the one carrying it?
You need to have a subscription to access this content in full.
Log in or subscribe today to unlock new features and receive Member Benefits.
